chickens

Feathered friends playing fowl hide-and-seek with their own breed

Well, this is one egg-citing mystery.

4 min readchickens
Feathered friends playing fowl hide-and-seek with their own breed
Mystery Chickens!

Okay, I need help identifying some of the chickens we have. My daughter hatched them for a 4H project and we have not been able to get any help identifying them. They are all show quality as she was supposed to show them at the fair but was unable to. This one is one of our largest chickens. My guesses were Ayam Cemani or black Sumatra. She does not appear to have any color on her aside from just under her beak there is a little bit of red like a very small waddle forming. Everything else is black including her eyes.

So your daughter's 4H project hatched a mystery that's got you playing detective in the coop, and honestly, this is the kind of fowl play I can get behind. You're leaning toward Ayam Cemani or Black Sumatra, and that's a solid starting point, but let's ruffle some feathers and get a little more precise. If this bird is truly black *everywhere*, including the eyes, beak, and skin, you're likely looking at an Ayam Cemani. Those birds are the goths of the chicken world: fully pigmented down to the bones. But that tiny red wattle forming under the beak? That's a clue worth chasing. Black Sumatras usually have a bit of purple or green sheen in their feathers, and their combs and wattles stay small and dark. If your girl is pure matte black with no iridescence and that single red hint, you might have a crossbreed or a very young Cemani still developing. It's a cluck-tastic puzzle, and I've seen similar head-scratchers from other folks in our community, like the one who posted about Cluck if you know what breed this feathery mystery is after finding a bird that defied all the usual ID charts.

Here's the thing about show-quality birds that don't get to the fair: they're still worth every bit of the effort your daughter poured in. The fact that she can't show them doesn't make them any less special, it just means you've got a backyard full of unique characters that need names and proper care. That red wattle you see is a good sign she's healthy and maturing, even if her breed is playing hard to get. I'd suggest checking her legs and feet: Ayam Cemanis have black skin there too, while Sumatras sometimes show slate or dark gray. If her legs are black as midnight, you're probably right about the Cemani. If they're a shade lighter, keep digging. And don't forget to look at her comb, if it's a walnut or pea shape, that's another clue pointing away from Sumatra. This whole situation reminds me of another reader who turned a chicken-themed decor crisis into a celebration when things didn't go as planned, proving that a little flexibility turns frustration into fun.

What matters most here is that you and your daughter have a healthy, striking bird that's clearly well cared for. Whether she's a rare Cemani or a mystery mix, she's a conversation starter and a testament to the patience of raising chicks from hatch. My advice? Snap a few clear photos of her legs, comb, and that wattle, then share them with a local poultry club or an online breed group. The folks who helped ID that mystery chicken in our earlier post might have the final answer. In the meantime, keep an eye on that red wattle, if it grows and stays red, you've got a hybrid. If it darkens to black, you've got a pure Cemani. Either way, that bird is show-stopping, fair or no fair.

From chickens

I need help identifying some of the chickens we have. My daughter hatched them for a 4H project and we have not been able to get any help identifying them. They are all show quality as she was supposed to show them at the fair but was unable to. This one is one of our largest chickens. My guesses were Ayam Cemani or black Sumatra. She does not appear to have any color on her aside from just under her beak there is a little bit of red like a very small waddle forming. Everything else is black including her…

Read the original at chickens