We don't know what they are either, and honestly? That's kind of the whole point. A Reddit user, /u/BluegrassSquatch, bought some black chicks from Tractor Supply this spring, raised them with love and patience, and now finds themselves staring at a flock of feathered mysteries. No breed tag. No helpful label. Just a bunch of black chickens who refuse to reveal their lineage. We've been there, not with these specific birds, but with the same sinking feeling that you've somehow adopted a dozen tiny enigmas. It's the same energy as watching Eleanor’s gone rogue: molting, hiding, and worrying this chicken mom sick, where a beloved hen suddenly becomes a stranger in your own coop. And just like When Your Pullet Plays Wing-Supported Hide and Seek for Two Days, sometimes the answers don't come easy, but the questions are what keep us clucking together.
This is the most relatable chicken problem we've seen all season. Tractor Supply sells chicks in bins labeled "straight run" or "assorted," and too often we walk out with a handful of peeping possibilities and zero guarantees. It's a gamble wrapped in feathers. And while some folks treat it like a fun surprise, ooh, what will we get?, the reality is that mystery birds come with mystery needs. You can't predict their size, their temperament, or their egg color. You can't prepare for a rooster if you weren't expecting one. You're basically playing fowl roulette, and the house doesn't always win. We think the industry could do better, but until then, the community fills the gap. That's where the real magic happens.
What does this mean for you? It means your chicken journey is never a straight line, and that's okay. The moment you think you've got it figured out, a black chick turns into a black chicken that looks nothing like the picture in the hatchery catalog. You start Googling "black chicken breed with green sheen" at 11 p.m. and end up in a forum thread from 2018. You post a photo and wait for the collective wisdom of people who have been exactly where you are. That's what /u/BluegrassSquatch did, and that's what we love about this corner of the internet. It's not about having the answer, it's about not having to face the mystery alone. Just like I poured my cluckin' heart and wallet into this speckled egg, the investment isn't just in the bird; it's in the shared experience.
So here's the concrete takeaway: if you bought chicks from a bin this spring, take a photo now. Write down where you got them and what the bin said. In six months, when your "black sex-link" turns out to be a Jersey Giant or a mysterious hybrid with a personality like a grumpy uncle, you'll want that breadcrumb trail. And if you're already staring at a flock of unknowns, don't panic, post your photos, tag us, and let the clucking chorus do its thing. The answer might not come today, but the conversation is worth more than any label.
