chickens

Two new girls, one mystery spur: help us crack this chocolate egg case

Just brought two more girls home, and one of them is already causing fowl play.

3 min readchickens
Two new girls, one mystery spur: help us crack this chocolate egg case
My two new hens(?)

We've got a mystery on our hands, and frankly, it's egg-citing. A new flock member shows up with spurs and a promise of chocolate eggs, and suddenly everyone's a detective. We love it. This isn't just another "what breed is my hen" post, it's a puzzle that connects right back to the big questions we all face in the coop: Are my girls weird, or is this normal? Can a hen have spurs without turning into a tiny dinosaur? And does a chocolate egg really taste different, or is it just the thrill of the hunt? We think the answer is simpler than you'd expect, but it opens a whole new can of scratch grains.

First, let's talk about those spurs. Yes, some hens grow them, especially certain breeds like Old English Game or even some Wyandottes. But here's the kicker: spurs can also pop up when a hen's hormones are a little out of whack, often due to ovarian issues. So the real question isn't just "what breed is she?" but "is she healthy?" We're not saying panic, far from it. Many spurred hens live long, happy lives laying Cluck-tastic personalities and whether your chickens have best friends alongside their flockmates. But it's worth keeping an eye on her energy and egg production. If she's still laying those chocolate beauties and acting like the queen of the run, she's probably fine. If she starts acting broody or aggressive, you might have a hormonal shift on your hands.

And about those chocolate eggs, they're real, and they're spectacular. Dark brown, almost reddish shells come from breeds like Marans, Welsummers, or certain crosses. The seller's claim that she lays chocolate eggs is a solid clue, but it's not a guarantee of breed purity. We've seen plenty of "chocolate egg layers" turn out to be mutts with a lucky gene. Honestly, that's part of the fun. You don't need a pedigree to appreciate a This sweetie melon is egg-citingly cute and cream-fully delicious moment when you crack one open for breakfast. The mystery of her heritage is what makes every egg a little surprise.

So what's the takeaway? Don't stress over the spurs or the shade of brown. Focus on behavior: Is she eating well? Is she integrating peacefully? Spurs are a feature, not a flaw, unless they're causing trouble. And if you really want to solve the breed puzzle, snap a clear photo of her comb, legs, and feather pattern, then compare with breed charts online. But honestly? The best part of this story isn't the answer, it's the fact that you brought home two new girls and you already love them, spurs and all. That's the kind of energy that makes a flock thrive. Now go watch her strut, and let us know if that first chocolate egg tastes as sweet as it looks.

From chickens

Just brought two more girls home to join my flock and the older hen has spurs? I’ve read this is normal but does it look like it’s because of her breed? Or hormonal? And if her breed, what is she? lol she was beautiful and the seller said she’s laying and lays more of a chocolate egg. I love all of our girls whether they lay or not just fyi.

Read the original at chickens