There's a special kind of heartbreak in watching your new hens get absolutely clobbered by the old guard, and our take is blunt: this isn't just fowl play, it's a full-blown coup that you absolutely can stop. The scene you described, bloody combs, cowering birds, a pecking order that turned into a pecking *war*, is every chicken keeper's nightmare, and it's also a classic case of introduction gone wrong. We've all been there, staring at a coop that looks more like a feathery boxing ring than a peaceful homestead, wondering if our This chicken made a kitchen pact and is sticking to it could ever coexist with the flock.
The good news is that the bullying you're seeing is predictable, not permanent. Your father did the right thing by quarantining the young hens until they were laying, but moving them in cold turkey, no pun intended, after they'd been separate for so long is like dropping a new kid into a high school cafeteria on the first day and expecting instant friendship. The established hens see them as invaders, not neighbors. The pecking, the blood, the refusal to let them eat or drink? That's the flock's way of saying "you don't belong here yet," and it's brutal but manageable. Compare this to the chaos of The great chicken escape: will our fence-jumper ever come back to the flock, where one bird simply left, here, nobody's running, they're just getting pummeled.
Here's the concrete takeaway: you need to reintroduce them slowly, using the "see but don't touch" method. Keep the new hens separated but visible, a wire divider inside the coop or run works wonders. Let them live side-by-side for a week, eating and drinking near each other without physical contact. This lets the old flock get used to their presence without the immediate urge to assert dominance. When you finally let them mingle, do it at dusk when chickens are sleepy and less aggressive, and add extra feeders and waterers so nobody gets cornered. The fact that your new hens didn't fight back isn't weakness; it's submission, which is actually a good sign, they're not trying to challenge the order, they just need a fair shot. And speaking of roosters causing trouble, My young rooster just turned into a feathered menace reminds us that sometimes the aggression comes from the top, but here it's a hen-on-hen grudge match.
One specific detail to watch: that torn comb isn't just cosmetic. Blood attracts more pecking, so treat any wounds with a blue-kote spray or similar antiseptic to mask the red and promote healing. If you can't reintegrate them peacefully after two more weeks of slow introductions, consider keeping the new hens as a separate mini-flock with their own coop space. Sometimes the pecking order is just too entrenched, and forcing it only leads to more bloodshed. But don't give up yet, your hens aren't monsters, they're just territorial. Give them a chance to learn that the new girls are flock, not foe.